Archos 5 Android IT Second Impressions

image Several weeks have passed since my first impressions of the Archos 5 Android Internet Tablet (A5AIT). I’ve spent a lot of time playing with it. As a result, I think I now have a better idea of what the A5AIT does well – and doesn’t do so well.

Identity Crisis

“Who am I”, asks my A5AIT. While hearing my A5AIT ask me questions doesn’t bode well for my mental state, it is a good question. And not just for the A5AIT, but for MIDs (mobile internet devices) generally, which can play one or more of the following roles:

-Very small laptop
-Web consumption device (Internet, Twitter, RSS, YouTube)
-PMP (portable media player)
-PIM (personal information manager)

I’ve folded the second category (web consumption) into the third (PMP) because of the overlap between them.

Substitute Laptop

Maybe in a pinch. Applications are available to read and in some cases edit word processing documents, spreadsheets, PDFs, etc. As discussed below under PIM, I have a decent substitute for Outlook.

However, many of my more specialized applications on my laptop (such as for law firms) run only on Windows; there’s no Android version. Perhaps that’s for the best. I’m not sure how well these hardware-intensive apps would run on the A5AIT’s limited processor and RAM. That’s no criticism of the A5AIT; it’s not designed for such heavy lifting. Instead, its primary purpose, and where it shines, is …

PMP

The web, videos and photos look great on the 4.8” 800×480 16 million color touchscreen. This is where the A5AIT shines over, say, the iPod Touch with its smaller 3.5” touchscreen. Yet, though the A5AIT’s touchscreen is relatively larger, it nevertheless is pocketable as I pointed out in my first impressions.

Audio sounds great. I use the Amazon MP3 application (free) to download songs. For podcasts, I use DoggCatcher ($6.99). There are of course alternative applications.

That’s not to say there aren’t issues. The primary one is that while the hardware supports flash, the browser doesn’t, yet anyway. Hopefully an OS update will resolve that. There also are some YouTube integration issues which hopefully will only be temporary. However, once these are resolved, the A5AIT will be a killer, pocketable PMP!

PIM

Warning: I’m using the 1.6.8 firmware version. It was withdrawn by Archos shortly after its release and hasn’t yet been updated by Archos. Many on the Archos Fans forum are using the 1.6.8 firmware version with no apparent problem. Further, Archos has recommended that those using the 1.6.8 version not roll back, and instead wait for a new 1.6.8 version (which hasn’t yet been released). Nevertheless, I can’t guarantee that those not using the current 1.6.8 version will be able to implement what I describe in this section. Additionally, I’ve implemented a hack that enables me to use Android Marketplace. This hack is unsupported by Archos; technical support is that found on the Archos Fans forum. I likewise can’t guarantee that those who don’t use this hack will be able to implement what I describe in this section.

In my hectic life, bouncing among teaching, law, network administration, etc., I rely heavily on my PIM to keep track of where I’m supposed to be and what I’m supposed to do. Given my gadget harem, I have many devices with the same PIM data. To keep them all on the same page, I need transparent synchronization of this data among multiple devices. Exchange Server mastered this many moons ago. Google … getting there, but not there yet.

Android – Hype, Hope or Reality criticized Android’s incomplete Exchange Server support. And that’s OS version 2.1. The A5AIT currently is at 1.6, which supports only IMAP and POP accounts; no Exchange Server at all.

Nevertheless, borrowing from the Apple folks, “there’s an app for that.” In this case, Touchdown by NitroDesk. With Touchdown, I can read the email, calendar, contacts and tasks from the hosted Exchange Server my law firm employer uses. But it gets better.

My community college employer also uses an Exchange Server. With Outlook 2007, you can access multiple Exchange Servers, but only on different profiles (Outlook 2010 permits you to do so on the same profile but it hasn’t been released yet). Each instance of Outlook can run only one profile at a time. Absent a hack (that’s another post), you can’t concurrently run multiple instances of Outlook. This means that, to switch between Exchange Servers, you have to close Outlook, then open it again with the different profile. A PITA.

With Touchdown, though, you can switch between profiles simply by clicking a file cabinet icon and choosing the other profile. You don’t have to exit and re-open the application. Very cool.

Support is email only. That worried me. However, I always received a response within an hour, sometimes within minutes. And it wasn’t canned answers as so often is the case. Instead, someone actually read my email.

Touchdown has a trial version, but it understandably isn’t free. In view of how well it solves my PIM/Exchange Server issue, and the good support, my $19.99 was well spent.

It takes a village

I rely on forums for help, and this is no exception. I’m still relatively new to Android, and the A5AIT’s implementation of Android is not the standard Google Experience version. I’ve found the A5AIT forum on Archos Fans (where I’m GenghisKhent) very helpful in getting answers. Also, like xda-developers for HTC Windows Mobile devices, the Archos Fans A5AIT forum also has hacks to expand the functionality of the A5AIT. One enables me to use Android Marketplace.

Conclusion so far

I’m enjoying the A5AIT, especially now that I can use it as a PIM. It’s claim to fame with me is a pocketable 4.8” device. The woods are full of 4.8” devices, but few are easily pocketable. Still, it’s work in process. An upgrade of the OS to 2.x, with built-in support for flash and Google Experience, would be a significant improvement.

I promised in first impressions to compare the A5AIT to my Viliv S5. Haven’t gotten there yet, but I will.

9 Responses to “Archos 5 Android IT Second Impressions”


  • Hey. Nice to see a long term look again at the A5.

    In the ‘Identity Crisis’ para you should mention that your A5 is actually not a true A5! (e.g. evololved to a hacked Google Android device)
    PIM functions simply don’t exist on a stock A5.

    How are you getting on with that hack though? I backed out.

    Oh, and are we up to V1.6 on Android officially? (You mention it in exchange support.)
    Sorry to be a picky so and so but I’m worried about people buying an A5 and wondering why they cant buy apps and cant sync contacts.

    Chippy

    • Hi Chippy! Excellent points.

      The 1.6 I’m running is what Archos pulled shortly after posting it around Xmas time. Archos said there would be fixed 1.6 within a few days. Nothing yet. No clear word either what was wrong with the 1.6 they pulled. The official reason was the browser, the scuttlebut was WiFi. I suspect from my own experience that WiFi is the reason; it disconnects too easily.

      The hack works for free apps. For paid apps there is a kludge that only works until you reboot.

      You may well be right — you know more about this stuff than I do — but I’m not sure Touchdown wouldn’t work but for the hack. I doubt it would be difficult to get the apk file outside of the market for the free trial, and you can activate it outside of the Android market, directly from the developer. And I’m not sure there’s anything about it that’s reliant on the Google Experience.

      I’ll update my post after I get back from a memorial for a family member who recently passed away. Appreciate any further input you may have.

    • I’ve now prefaced the PIM section with an appropriate warning.

  • Sounds like 1.6 + Google hack is working well for you. I might give it a second chance soon.
    I’m currently not too positive about using the device for any business work but still use it every day at home.

    If the Dell Mini 5 comes with true google Android however, I might be tempted!

    • The Dell Mini 5 also can serve as a phone. Not clear if it has an earpiece, or not like the HTC Advantage.

      Also unclear is if the Dell Mini 5 will be pocketable like the A5AIT, or not really, like the HTC Advantage.

      Like you, I certainly will be keeping my eye out on this device.

  • The A5A with the 1.6 FW is working pretty well for me — and the market hack is fairly simple. I still get occasional freezes in YouTube or random slowdowns, but I use it daily, and paired with a Mifi it is a great mobile solution. Also, you can use Touchdown without the market hack. It’s available at the AndApp store, which you can access on the web and download their store app.

    • gmich, thanks for verifying that Touchdown works without the hack. It seemed logical that it would, but you never know.

      YouTube is still problematic. I suspect this will be fixed in a firmware upgrade.

      I too use the MiFi with my A5AIT. The only problem with the MiFi is the battery life. So I bought an extra battery. With a MiFi, no need for a dedicated SIM, or built-in 3G for that matter.

  • I currently have the A5IT and even though there is no real exchange support I was able to Get the work email client.apk and installed it on my A5IT. There’s no real support for contacts and calander but I am able to get work emails without issues. I used an app to sd application on my android Phone to copy over the Apk. Note not all Apk files will copy to SD.

  • Hi all, I think this information can be useful for you. If you plan to get your website, here is one good web hosting provider to choose – mochahost.com – 1,95$ per Month. You can register with this link to get special offer: mochahost.com They provide very cheap and very Fast hosting for the buck, there is no catch. You get UNLIMITED of disk space and UNLIMITED bandwidth. They also have cPanel control panel which is amazing and easy to use website builder. They also have UNLIMITED : E-mail Accounts Parked Domains Support Sub-Domains Support MySQL Database Support Moreover, there is no any kind of advertising on your pages. Thanks For Attention!

Comments are currently closed.